Tuesday, March 15, 2016

A Small Place by Jamaica Kincaid


As I was reading "A Small Place" by Jamaica Kincaid I couldn't stop myself from relating this novel with my hometown (Puerto Rico). I saw how this strong women has strict feelings about her hometown, government, and tourists, and I don't mean the same feelings for all of them.A couple of quotes to show her themes would be first, the first sentence of the novel where she states, "THE ANTIGUA that I knew, the Antigua in which I grew up, is not the Antigua you, a tourist, would see now." I see how she makes a separation between the hometown she knows and the one that tourists go. It is important to recognize these distinctions because she later on explains why and I feel in some way connected to that. Maybe it's because Puerto Rico is a tourist place where people enjoy visiting on the holidays to enjoy the sun and the beaches. I sometimes wonder if the people who visit here really sees the problems that are occurring with our government and not only that but the economic issues that we deal with day by day. Maybe I'm a little exaggerating because our social problem is not really as huge as Jamaica Kincaid explains in her novel, but still I could see it becoming that way if we continue and worsen our problems. Also, Jamaica Kincaid illustrates how messed up is the system in the government and how affected she is by it. This can be seen when she says, "Do you ever try to understand why people like me cannot get over the past, cannot forgive and cannot forget?" When I first read this, I felt so connected to this sentence. She really shows how much it bothers her and I also found how interesting how she classifies herself saying, "people like me" where she literally feels judged and categorized. Finally, she keeps talking about the government and the tourists where she makes an example of a library that needed to be fixed and never was. This can be seen when she says, "'REPAIRS ARE PENDING, and here it is many years later, but perhaps in a world that is twelve miles long and nine miles wide (the side of Antigua) twelve years and twelve minutes and twelve days are all the same.” I quite like this example of her because one can see how the government promises new opportunities and visions where nothing is really done. I can relate to this with Puerto Rico because most of the time that is what happens in our government. I mean the governors that get elected here make so many promises that at the end of the day they don’t even make one true. So I felt in that moment as I read Jamaica Kincaid story her anger.

4 comments:

  1. I wholeheartedly agree with your connection of Puerto Rico and Antigua. The issue with all of our interpretations of Jamaica Kincaid's A Small Place is that we all connect it to our own Island because it is a very similar situation and as much as we want to say that its not worse than Antigua's situation we have to accept that each situation is individual even if they are similar. We both share corruption in our government, in their case its the Car Loans and with us its the monopolization of water and electric distribution. The point of it all is that we cant determine that our situation is less important than Antigua's just because they have it worse than we do, everyone in this world, every country is suffering in some degree but none of them are less or more important.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree, puertoricans have a strong feeling about the country they live in we praise and criticize just as harshly our homeland more than anybody else. The island as definitely changed for better or worst and tourist surely don't see the part and problems of the island that we see. I wonder if foreigners see what we see too. We can reach those severe problems if we keep going the way we are. I never noticed now that you mention it that Jamaica does distance herself from the reader the tourist and Antigua in a way. I wonder why? You can definitely feel the authors anger. Finally, corruption is definitely a big issue both in Antigua and here in Puerto Rico.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is definitely easy to make the connection between the two islands and connect with her frustrations. Tourists come and see how quaint and how different, but they can't connect to the reality of the island because it's just a good time for them. However, as Kinkaid says, we're all susceptible to this when we travel (except for those who cannot leave). It is a sad reality that we're living in our island, but because of this reason we have to strive to make this a better island so we have no reason to envy the tourists and be happy with our situation.

    ReplyDelete
  4. In your post you establish that you sometimes wonder if the people who visit Puerto Rico really see the problems that are occurring with our government and not only that but the economic issues that we deal with as well. What do you think is the answer?

    ReplyDelete